Palm Bay, FL – The Palm Bayer has issued a formal candidate readiness assessment to the six candidates running for City Council Seats 4 and 5. Rather than distributing standard candidate questionnaires that allow for pre-written campaign platform statements, this assessment is structured as an open-book, take-home examination on the mechanics of local governance and budget allocation.
Candidates have until noon on July 7, 2026, to return their responses. All answers will be published completely raw and unedited, providing voters with a direct look at each candidate’s attention to detail, research habits, and familiarity with the city they wish to govern. If a candidate declines to participate, their profile will be published with a blank exam sheet and a note stating they declined the assessment.
Why Traditional Candidate Questionnaires Fail Voters
Traditional political surveys invite canned responses. Campaign consultants write the answers, ensuring they remain safe, focus-tested, and free of controversial positions. This leaves voters with a barrage of generic platitudes about improving roads and supporting public safety, without any explanation of how candidates will accomplish these goals.
A municipal government is a multi-million-dollar operation. Governing requires a functional understanding of local ordinances, charter boundaries, and funding mechanisms. The Palm Bayer Readiness Assessment addresses this by testing candidates on the actual business of the City of Palm Bay.
What the Palm Bay Candidate Assessment Covers
The assessment is divided into three distinct parts, focusing on practical knowledge and scenario-based decision making.
Part 1: Local Governance and City Operations
The first part tests factual knowledge of local governance and city operations. Candidates must explain the explicit charter line of authority between the City Council, the City Manager, and department heads. They must also analyze the current millage rate of 6.7339 mills and address the historical causes of the severe infrastructure deficit in the Southwest quadrant.
Part 2: Realistic Governance Scenarios
The second part presents three realistic, no-win scenarios that council members frequently face. The first scenario details a zoning variance and impact fee waiver proposal for a high-density development adjacent to a failing roadway. The second details a budget workshop conflict where rising construction costs force a choice between neighborhood road repaving and municipal employee salary adjustments. The third requires a vote on expanding city-funded automated license plate readers and integrating private neighborhood feeds into the police database.
Part 3: Leadership and Public Pressure
The third part addresses leadership philosophy and public pressure. It includes scenarios on how candidates vote when facing vocal public opposition to a project that prevents flooding in a lower-income neighborhood. It also asks how they handle reversing a public position when presented with new data, and how they represent their constituents when consistently on the losing end of a 4-1 council split.
Open Research Resources for Candidates and Voters
This is not a closed-book pop quiz designed to catch candidates off guard. It is a take-home exam. Candidates are encouraged to research city records, study the City Charter, and search municipal budgets.
To ensure a level playing field, The Palm Bayer has provided all candidates with access to a public research engine. The workspace contains thousands of pages of Palm Bay municipal records, charter revisions, and infrastructure studies. The public is also invited to use this research engine to study the same data and verify the facts for themselves.
Candidate Directory
City Council Seat 4
Kenny Johnson (Incumbent)
Campaign Website: johnson4palmbay.com
Campaign Email: johnson4palmbay@gmail.com
Phone: No campaign phone registered
Alfred Ramsay “Alfy” Agarie
Campaign Website: None registered
Campaign Email: alfyagarie@gmail.com
Phone: (321) 508-0628
Michael J. Bruyette
Campaign Website: None registered
Campaign Email: mbruyette922@gmail.com
Phone: No campaign phone registered
City Council Seat 5
Mike Jaffe (Incumbent)
Campaign Website: mikejaffeforpalmbay.com
Campaign Email: mjaffe@thejaffegroupfl.com
Phone: No campaign phone registered
Santa Isabel Wright
Campaign Website: None registered
Campaign Email: MRSISABELWRIGHT@AOL.COM
Phone: No campaign phone registered
Eduardo Macaya
Campaign Website: None registered
Campaign Email: coachmacaya4palmbay@gmail.com
Phone: (321) 537-5767
This story is also published at news.thepalmbayer.com/news/palm-bay-candidate-readiness-assessment-launch/ with additional inline visuals, related coverage links, and a video embed where available.
Sources
