🌴 Palm Bay City Council Voting Record 2021 - 2024 (Present) ✅
Outline of all items brought before the Palm Bay City Council that did not receive unanimous support.
Editor’s note:
In the dynamic realm of politics, transparency and accountability are crucial for effective governance. I’ve compiled a detailed outline of Palm Bay City Council’s voting records from 2021 to 2024, providing a valuable resource for residents to track their representatives’ voting behaviors. This document highlights every non-unanimous vote, enabling voters to assess whether their representatives’ decisions align with their personal values and priorities. As the 2024 re-elections draw near, this voting record becomes essential for making informed choices at the polls.
Utilizing advanced AI technology and all of the City Council minutes back to January 2021, I’ve created a comprehensive report on voting patterns. This data-driven approach allows residents to analyze trends and gain insights into our local government’s decision-making processes. I believe this information is crucial for those wanting to stay informed and actively participate in local politics.
I have formatted this page to make it easily accessible by online AI tools. You may want direct your favorite AI to this page and ask “how did [insert name] vote when it came to [topic]?”, or most any other question about the actions of the City Council over the last 3 1/2 years.
This strategy enhances transparency and accountability by providing clear, accessible information on how our City Council votes, helping residents hold officials accountable and make educated decisions in elections. I hope this report will be a valuable tool for increasing civic engagement in our community.
Stay informed,
Tom
Meeting 2021-01 (January 7, 2021):
Ordinance 2020-58, Eliminating Building Permit Requirement for Small Accessory Structures (Final Reading)
Case: T-20-2020, City of Palm Bay
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2020-58
Discussion Summary: Aim to eliminate building permit requirement for accessory structures under 120 sq ft for single-family dwellings.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Bailey, Councilman Foster
Nays: Councilman Felix
Discussion of the Position of City Manager
Motion 1: To appoint Suzanne Sherman as City Manager, with Councilman Foster negotiating the contract.
Discussion Summary: Debate on appointing Ms. Sherman (Acting City Manager) or conducting a formal search. Concerns about transparency and due process due to the late agenda addition.
Voting Outcome 1: 3-2
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Councilman Bailey
Motion 2: To have Deputy Mayor Johnson negotiate Ms. Sherman's contract.
Discussion Summary: Discussion on who should negotiate the employment contract.
Voting Outcome 2: 3-2
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina, Councilman Bailey
Meeting 2021-02 (January 21, 2021):
Resolution 2021-06, Amending Five-Year Capital Improvements Program (First Amendment)
Motion: To adopt Resolution 2021-06
Discussion Summary: Questions about City expenses for Drive Through Light Festival and reallocation of funds from various projects.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Councilman Bailey
Consideration of Amendment to Council Policies and Procedures Regarding Meeting Rules and Order
Motion 1: To amend Council Policies and Procedures as requested.
Discussion Summary: Proposal to prohibit adding agenda items after packet distribution for transparency. Debate on balancing transparency and flexibility for time-sensitive issues.
Voting Outcome 1: 2-3
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Councilman Bailey
Nays: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Motion 2: To amend the motion with revised language proposed by Councilman Bailey.
Discussion Summary: Councilman Bailey proposed alternative language to balance transparency and flexibility.
Voting Outcome 2: 2-3
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Councilman Bailey
Nays: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Consideration of Employment Agreement with Suzanne Sherman, City Manager
Motion: To approve the employment agreement with annual salary of $185,000.
Discussion Summary: Discussion on the terms of the agreement, including salary and severance package.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Bailey, Councilman Foster
Nays: Councilman Felix
Meeting 2021-04 (February 4, 2021):
Resolution 2021-08, Urging Florida Legislature to Approve Medicaid Expansion
Motion: To adopt Resolution 2021-08
Discussion Summary: Resolution urging Medicaid expansion for benefits to uninsured Floridians. Debate on alignment with City priorities.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina, Councilman Bailey
Meeting 2021-05 (February 18, 2021):
Ordinance 2021-07, Changing Land Use to Multiple Family Residential (9.99 acres)
Case: CP-2-2021, Palm Bay Greens, LLC
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2021-07 with conditions (traffic impact analysis, environmental study, density cap).
Discussion Summary: Concerns from residents about increased density, traffic, and environmental impacts.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Bailey, Councilman Foster
Nays: Councilman Felix
Resolution 2021-10, Approving Planned Unit Development (PUD) Preliminary Development Plan (74.24 acres)
Case: PD-2-2021, Palm Bay Greens, LLC
Motion: To adopt Resolution 2021-10 with conditions (preliminary plat, title opinion, covenants, construction drawings, environmental study, traffic analysis, amenities, square footage requirements).
Discussion Summary: Concerns about lot sizes, square footage, and impact on existing homeowners.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Bailey, Councilman Foster
Nays: Councilman Felix
Ground Lease Agreement with Brightline Trains Florida, LLC for Railroad Bridge Construction
Motion: To approve the Ground Lease Agreement.
Discussion Summary: Discussion of lease rate and project benefits for the new railroad bridge over Turkey Creek.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Councilman Bailey
Advancing Unit 30 in GO Road Bond Paving Program Phase 2
Motion: To approve advancing Unit 30 (Madden Avenue and Osmosis Drive).
Discussion Summary: Debate on prioritizing these streets despite the small number of homes.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Councilman Bailey
Consideration of Stance on Proposed State Bills
Motion: To oppose bills related to vacation rentals.
Discussion Summary: Discussion of City's stance on various bills including vacation rentals, home-based businesses, impact fees, and sales/use tax.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Councilman Bailey
Motion: To oppose bills related to home-based businesses.
Discussion Summary: (Same as above)
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Councilman Bailey
Motion: To oppose bills related to impact fees.
Discussion Summary: (Same as above)
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Councilman Bailey
Motion: To support bills related to sales and use tax.
Discussion Summary: (Same as above)
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina, Councilman Bailey
Meeting 2021-13 (June 3, 2021):
Ordinance 2021-33, Modifying Provisions for Parks and Recreation Department (First Reading)
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2021-33.
Discussion Summary: Proposal to separate Parks and Facilities from Recreation. Concerns about effectiveness and impact on service delivery.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Councilman Bailey
Ordinance 2021-38, Creating Parks and Facilities Department (First Reading)
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2021-38.
Discussion Summary: Formal establishment of Parks and Facilities Department following reorganization.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Councilman Bailey
Consideration of Amendment to Redevelopment Incentive Agreement with NorthShore Development, LLC
Motion 1: To deny the amendment request.
Discussion Summary: Amendment proposed changes including project extension and property bifurcation. Concerns about developer commitment and impact on tax base.
Voting Outcome 1: 2-3
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Councilman Bailey
Nays: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Motion 2: To approve the amendment request.
Discussion Summary: Reconsideration of the amendment after initial denial.
Voting Outcome 2: 3-2
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina, Councilman Bailey
Meeting 2021-18 (July 15, 2021):
Resolution 2021-35, Amending Classification and Pay Plans and Position Control Plan (Third Amendment)
Motion: To adopt Resolution 2021-35.
Discussion Summary: Amendment included eliminating a Public Works maintenance position, raising concerns about staffing and service delivery.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Councilman Bailey
Ordinance 2021-50, Updating Provisions in Elections Code (First Reading)
Motion 1: To approve Ordinance 2021-50.
Discussion Summary: Proposal to remove 12-month timeframe for filling City Council vacancies, raising concerns about voter disenfranchisement and accountability.
Voting Outcome 1: Failed 2-3
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina, Councilman Bailey, Councilman Felix
Motion 2: To appoint a qualified individual until special election within 75-180 days.
Discussion Summary: Alternative approach to filling vacancies involving temporary appointment until election.
Voting Outcome 2: Passed 3-2
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina, Councilman Bailey
Meeting 2021-19 (August 5, 2021):
Ordinance 2021-50, Updating Provisions in Elections Code (Final Reading)
Motion 1: To withdraw Item 2 (ordinance) from Public Hearings.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about tie votes and maintaining a full Council for effective governance.
Voting Outcome 1: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Bailey, Councilman Foster
Nays: Councilman Felix
Motion 2: To adopt Ordinance 2021-50 with removal of subsection related to vacancy timeframe.
Discussion Summary: Alternative approach to remove specific subsection on 12-month timeframe.
Voting Outcome 2: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Bailey, Councilman Foster
Nays: Councilman Felix
Resolution 2021-38, Conveying Surplus Real Estate (Pelican Harbor Marina)
Motion: To adopt Resolution 2021-38.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about proposed sale price and whether it reflects fair market value.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Councilman Bailey, Councilman Felix
Ordinance 2021-48, Establishing Regulations for Golf Carts (Final Reading)
Case: T-19-2021, Emerald Investment Holdings, LLC
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2021-48.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about safety, especially when crossing major roadways.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Councilman Bailey
Consideration of Salary Increase for Information Technology Director
Motion: To authorize increase from $85,258 to $105,000.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about the size of the proposed increase.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Councilman Bailey
Consideration of Appropriation for Shelter Replacement at Castaways Point Park
Motion: To approve appropriation from Undesignated Fund Balance as requested ($29,069).
Discussion Summary: Concerns about cost and prioritization of the project.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Councilman Bailey
Meeting 2021-22 (September 2, 2021):
Ordinance 2021-81, Including Brew Pubs in HC Zoning (Final Reading)
Case: T23-00015, City of Palm Bay
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2021-81
Discussion Summary: Aim to allow brew pubs and other drinking establishments in Highway Commercial District.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina, Councilman Bailey
Ordinance 2021-82, Modifying Setback Requirements for Interchange Signs (Final Reading)
Case: T23-00017, All Digital All Day, LLC
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2021-82
Discussion Summary: Concerns about potential visual impact and safety considerations.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Bailey
Meeting 2021-24 (September 16, 2021):
Consideration of Tentative Millage Rate for Tax Year 2021
Motion: To set the tentative millage rate at 7.5995.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about exceeding 3% cap and impact on taxpayers. Balancing fiscal responsibility with service demands due to growth.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina, Councilman Bailey
Consideration of Purchase Offer for City-Owned Surplus Real Estate
Motion: To authorize purchase contract for $135,505.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about sale price and potential need for infrastructure improvements.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Councilman Bailey
Meeting 2021-28 (October 21, 2021):
Resolution 2021-38, Conveying Surplus Real Estate (Pelican Harbor Marina)
Motion: To adopt Resolution 2021-38.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about sale price, impact of undisclosed lease agreement, and property valuation.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Councilman Bailey, Councilman Felix
Resolution 2021-41, Extending Commencement Period for Self-Storage Facility
Location: East of and adjacent to Babcock Street, west of Hardin Lane (2.45 acres) (Case CU-45-2022, Fred D. Boozer, Jr.)
Motion: To adopt Resolution 2021-41, with amendment to grant 6-month extension.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about lack of job creation and prioritization of economic development projects.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Foster
Nays: Councilman Johnson
Continuation of Discussion Regarding Campground Project Next Steps
Motion: To amend motion to direct staff to negotiate design task order for bridge only and other park improvements.
Discussion Summary: Discussion of next steps, budget, impact fees, and return on investment.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Deputy Mayor Felix
Meeting 2021-29 (November 4, 2021):
Ordinance 2021-89, Removing Code Compliance Division from Growth Management Department (First Reading)
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2021-89.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about potential conflicts of interest and separation of duties.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina
Ordinance 2021-90, Placing Code Compliance Division under Building Department (First Reading)
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2021-90.
Discussion Summary: Formal placement of Code Compliance under Building Department following removal from Growth Management.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina
Consideration of Salary Increase for Chief Building Official
Motion: To approve salary increase as requested (11%).
Discussion Summary: Concerns about the size of the increase and use of General Fund monies.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina
Ordinance 2021-115, Creating School Zone Speed Infractions Chapter (First Reading)
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2021-114.
Discussion Summary: Establishing regulations for school zone speed infractions and authorizing speed detection system. Concerns about effectiveness and impact on drivers.
Voting Outcome: 4-0
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Ordinance 2021-116, Modifying Timelines for Preliminary Development Plan Submittals (First Reading)
Case: T23-00028, City of Palm Bay
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2021-115.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about potential delays and impact on developers.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson
Nays: Councilman Foster
Meeting 2021-31 (December 2, 2021):
Ordinance 2021-89, Removing Code Compliance Division from Growth Management Department (First Reading)
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2021-89.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about potential commingling of funds between Building Department and Code Compliance.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina
Ordinance 2021-90, Placing Code Compliance Division under Building Department (First Reading)
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2021-90.
Discussion Summary: Formal placement of Code Compliance under Building Department.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina
Consideration of Salary Increase for Chief Building Official
Motion: To approve salary increase as requested (11%).
Discussion Summary: Concerns about the size of the increase and use of General Fund monies.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina
Ordinance 2021-86, Changing Land Use to Multiple Family Residential (21.00 acres)
Case: CP-17-2021, Diocese of Orlando
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2021-86 with conditions.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about increased density, traffic, and impact on surrounding neighborhoods.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina
Resolution 2021-71, Approving Planned Unit Development (PUD) Preliminary Development Plan (21.00 acres)
Case: PD-50-2021, Diocese of Orlando
Motion: To adopt Resolution 2021-71 with conditions.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about potential impact on traffic, infrastructure, and surrounding neighborhood.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina
Ordinance 2021-116, Modifying Timelines for Preliminary Development Plan Submittals (First Reading)
Case: T23-00028, City of Palm Bay
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2021-115.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about potential delays and impact on developers.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson
Nays: Councilman Foster
Ordinance 2021-112, Changing Land Use to High-Density Residential (7.02 acres)
Case: CP23-00018, Treeland Apartments, LLC
Motion: To deny Ordinance 2021-112.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about increased traffic, impact on infrastructure, and potential for alternative uses like light industrial.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson
Nays: Councilman Foster
Consideration of Pursuing Legal Action for Code Violations at 1798 Glenwood Street NE
Motion: To authorize legal action to facilitate clean-up of the property.
Discussion Summary: Discussion of property with ongoing code violations and potential for legal action. Concerns about effectiveness and ongoing problems.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Councilman Bailey
Meeting 2022-01 (January 6, 2022):
Ordinance 2022-09, Changing Land Use to Mixed Use (23.86 acres)
Case: CP-13-2021, Sachs Capital Group, LP and Identical Investments, LLC
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2022-09.
Discussion Summary: Rezoning request for former Majors Golf Course property. Concerns about traffic, density, need for additional entrance/exit, and impact on single-family residential areas. Support for affordable housing and positive impact on blighted property.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina
Resolution 2022-02, Approving Preliminary Development Plan for 'Jupiter Bay PUD' (23.86 acres)
Case: PD-48-2021, Sachs Capital Group, LP and Identical Investments, LLC
Motion: To adopt Resolution 2022-02 with conditions (preliminary plat, title opinion, development standards, construction drawings, school concurrency, environmental assessments, lighting, access, emergency exit).
Discussion Summary: Similar concerns and support as land use change vote, with focus on conditions and impact on neighboring landlocked parcel.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina
Meeting 2022-04 (February 17, 2022):
Ordinance 2022-29, Approving Final Development Plan for 'Richmond Cove PUD' (29.15 acres)
Case: FD-4-2022, RKF Residential Development Properties, LLC
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2022-29.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about PUD development surrounded by Rural Residential zoning and potential utility service challenges. Discussion of eminent domain for right-of-way acquisition.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina
Meeting 2022-05 (March 3, 2022):
Consideration of Co-Sponsorship with Court Kingz for Summer Basketball League
Motion: To approve co-sponsorship for a total cost of $5,815.60.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about using taxpayer funds for non-profit events. Supporters highlighted community benefits and participant taxpayer status.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Councilman Filiberto
Consideration of Co-Sponsorship for Caribbean American Heritage Month Events
Motion: To approve co-sponsorship with BCASCA for a total cost of $6,888.25.
Discussion Summary: Similar concerns about taxpayer funds and non-annual events. Support for economic benefits and cultural value.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Councilman Filiberto
Meeting 2022-06 (March 17, 2022):
Resolution 2022-13, Adopting Vision Zero Goal for Road Safety
Motion: To table the item to the next regular meeting.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about resolution being politically charged, unconstitutional, and potential for racial profiling. Support for road safety and focus on engineering, education, and enforcement.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Councilman Filiberto
Meeting 2022-08 (April 7, 2022):
Ordinance 2022-29, Approving Final Development Plan for 'Richmond Cove PUD' (29.15 acres)
Case: FD-4-2022, RKF Residential Development Properties, LLC
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2022-29 with conditions.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about PUD development surrounded by Rural Residential zoning and lack of existing utility services. Discussion of potential eminent domain use.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina
Meeting 2022-19 (July 7, 2022):
Ordinance 2022-70, Changing Land Use to Multiple-Family Residential (191 acres)
Case: CP-14-2022, PF Naples, LLC
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2022-70.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about noise conflict with adjacent BRP facility, lack of amenities, and need for smart growth. Support for economic benefits and potential commercial development.
Voting Outcome: 2-3
Yeas: Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Filiberto
Resolution 2022-37, Approving Preliminary Development Plan for 'DeGroodt PUD' (43.55 acres)
Case: PD-21-2022, Kew, LLC
Motion: To adopt Resolution 2022-37 with conditions (staff comments, traffic impact study).
Discussion Summary: Concerns focused on traffic study and potential requirement for road connections and traffic signal.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix, Councilman Filiberto
Nays: Mayor Medina
Ordinance 2022-73, Establishing Provisions for Administrative Variances and Voluntary Inclusionary Housing
Case: T-27-2022, City of Palm Bay
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2022-73.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about potential abuse of process and lack of guidelines for voluntary inclusionary housing. Support for flexibility and efficiency in development review.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Councilman Filiberto
Ordinance 2022-76, Changing Land Use to Commercial and Single-Family Residential (43.55 acres)
Case: CP-21-2022, Kew, LLC
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2022-76.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about loss of green space and impact on traffic and infrastructure. Support for alignment with City's vision and economic benefits.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix, Councilman Filiberto
Nays: Mayor Medina
Resolution 2022-37, Approving Preliminary Development Plan for 'DeGroodt PUD' (43.55 acres)
Case: PD-21-2022, Kew, LLC
Motion: To adopt Resolution 2022-37 with conditions.
Discussion Summary: Similar concerns and discussion as land use change vote, with emphasis on traffic study and potential road connection/signal requirements.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix, Councilman Filiberto
Nays: Mayor Medina
Ordinance 2022-77, Providing for Referendum Election on City Charter Amendments
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2022-77.
Discussion Summary: Mayor disagreed with some proposed amendments and opposed the item.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix, Councilman Filiberto
Nays: Mayor Medina
Meeting 2022-22 (August 18, 2022):
Ordinance 2022-100, Temporary Moratorium on Residential Development Applications
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2022-100 with amendments (effect until Sept. 6, 2022, and excluding projects with pre-application meetings).
Discussion Summary: Concerns about impact on developers and job losses. Support for addressing infrastructure and public safety concerns.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina, Councilman Filiberto
Consideration of Reallocating ARPA Funds and Appropriating Funds for Financial System Replacement
Motion: To approve reallocation of $2 million in ARPA funds for Emergency Operations Center and $2 million from General Fund for financial system replacement.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about project prioritization and potential need for public safety funding.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix, Councilman Filiberto
Nays: Deputy Mayor Johnson
Meeting 2022-24 (September 1, 2022):
Ordinance 2022-90, Changing Land Use to Multiple-Family Residential (3.00 acres)
Case: CP-17-2022, Dudley E. Garner and Sue E. Garner Revocable Trust
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2022-90.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about loss of industrial land and potential traffic/stormwater issues. Support for diverse housing options and alignment with Comprehensive Plan.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina, Councilman Filiberto
Ordinance 2022-91, Rezoning Property to RM-15 (3.00 acres)
Case: CPZ-17-2022, Dudley E. Garner and Sue E. Garner Revocable Trust
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2022-91 with condition of substantial conformance to concept plan.
Discussion Summary: Similar concerns and discussion as land use change vote, with focus on impact on neighborhood and resident demographics.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina, Councilman Filiberto
Ordinance 2022-92, Removing Restrictions on Arcade Amusement Centers
Case: T-40-2022, City of Palm Bay
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2022-92.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about potential negative impacts of such businesses on the community.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix, Councilman Filiberto
Nays: Mayor Medina
Meeting 2022-26 (September 15, 2022):
Ordinance 2022-100, Temporary Moratorium on Residential Development Applications
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2022-100 with amendments (effect until Sept. 6, 2022, and excluding projects with pre-application meetings).
Discussion Summary: Concerns about impact on developers and job losses. Support for addressing infrastructure and public safety concerns.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina, Councilman Filiberto
Ordinance 2022-60, Changing Land Use to Commercial (6.177 acres)
Case: CP-19-2022, Thomas C. and Ruth Z. Welsh Trust
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2022-60.
Discussion Summary: Concerns from residents about increased traffic, noise, crime, and negative impact on residential area.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Councilman Felix, Councilman Filiberto
Ordinance 2022-61, Rezoning Property to RC (6.177 acres)
Case: CPZ-19-2022, Thomas C. and Ruth Z. Welsh Trust
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2022-61 with condition of eliminating connection to Rue Street.
Discussion Summary: Similar concerns as land use change vote, with focus on traffic and safety in residential area.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Councilman Felix, Councilman Filiberto
Ordinance 2022-68, Changing Land Use to Mixed Use (0.83 acres)
Case: CP-16-2022, Sachs Capital Group, LP and Identical Investments, LLC
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2022-68.
Discussion Summary: Mayor opposed, preferring single-family homes. Concerns about traffic on Jupiter Boulevard.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina, Councilman Filiberto
Resolution 2022-29, Approving Preliminary Development Plan for 'Jupiter Bay PUD' (24.69 acres)
Case: PD-15-2022, Sachs Capital Group, LP and Identical Investments, LLC
Motion: To adopt Resolution 2022-29 with conditions (staff and Planning and Zoning Board).
Discussion Summary: Discussion of conditions including turn lane and density concerns with condominiums.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina, Councilman Filiberto
Resolution 2022-42, Granting Conditional Use for Storage of Liquefied Petroleum Products and Chemicals
Case: CU-35-2022, Joseph Beatty, FAR Research, Inc.
Motion: To approve Resolution 2022-42.
Discussion Summary: Discussion of past incidents and potential risks. Support for applicant's commitment to safety and economic benefits.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix, Councilman Filiberto
Nays: Mayor Medina
Meeting 2022-27 (September 21, 2022):
Ordinance 2022-96, Adjusting Rates for City Utilities System
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2022-96.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about utility rate increases.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina, Councilman Filiberto
Ordinance 2022-97, Adjusting Wastewater System Permit Fees
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2022-97.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about wastewater fee increases.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina, Councilman Filiberto
Ordinance 2022-98, Adjusting Reclaimed Water Rates
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2022-98.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about reclaimed water rate adjustments.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Councilman Filiberto
Resolution 2022-53, Declaring Critical Need Funding for FY 2022-2023
Motion: To adopt Resolution 2022-53.
Discussion Summary: Aim to exceed 3% cap on operating millage rate.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix, Councilman Filiberto
Nays: Deputy Mayor Johnson
Resolution 2022-54, Approving Millage Rates for FY 2022-2023
Motion: To adopt Resolution 2022-54.
Discussion Summary: Approval of millage rates for the upcoming fiscal year.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix, Councilman Filiberto
Nays: Deputy Mayor Johnson
Consideration of Departmental Travel and Training for FY 2022-2023
Motion: To approve with addition of monthly reporting.
Discussion Summary: Preference for individual approvals throughout the year.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Councilman Filiberto
Meeting 2022-28 (September 22, 2022):
Application by Community of Hope, Inc. for ARPA Funding
Motion: To approve $1,231,320 for Baywood Townhomes project.
Discussion Summary: Request for ARPA funds for affordable housing.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Felix
Nays: Councilman Foster, Councilman Filiberto
Application by I am Ministries Inc. for ARPA Funding
Motion: To approve funding in the amount of $1,299,000.
Discussion Summary: Request for ARPA funds for homelessness and affordable housing programs.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina, Councilman Filiberto
Meeting 2022-31 (October 20, 2022):
Ordinance 2022-101, Approving Preliminary Development Plan for '3 Forks Mixed Use' (124.33 acres)
Case: PD-26-2022, Parkside Commons Center, LLC, and West 80 Acres, LLC
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2022-101 with conditions.
Discussion Summary: Approval for preliminary development plan of mixed-use development.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix, Councilman Filiberto
Nays: Mayor Medina
Ordinance 2022-102, Approving Final Development Plan for 'Chaparral Phases IV and V' (160.51 acres)
Case: FD-16-2022, Chaparral Properties, LLC
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2022-102 with conditions.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about project density and potential impacts on traffic and environment.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Felix
Nays: Mayor Medina, Councilman Filiberto
Ordinance 2022-112, Rezoning Property to RM-15 (18.44 acres)
Case: Z-44-2022, ACIS Investment Group, LLC
Motion: To deny Ordinance 2022-112.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about traffic and lack of infrastructure for higher density development.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Filiberto
Nays: Councilman Foster
Meeting 2022-31 (October 20, 2022) continued:
Ordinance 2022-119, Modifying Provisions for Unimproved Real Property
Case: T-57-2022, City of Palm Bay
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2022-119.
Discussion Summary: Stricter regulations for unimproved property impacting Majors Golf Course. Concerns from owner about financial burden, support from residents due to property condition.
Voting Outcome: 5-0
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster, Councilman Filiberto
Resolution 2022-58, Imposing Stormwater Utility Fees
Motion: To adopt Resolution 2022-58, repeal/replace Resolutions 2020-35 and 2020-40, and approve funding for institutional property exemptions.
Discussion Summary: Modification of stormwater utility fee structure to remove exemptions for institutional properties. Concerns from churches about financial impact.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina, Councilman Filiberto
Amending Council Policies and Procedures to Include Curfew for Regular Meetings
Motion: To approve amendment to Section 5.1 with curfew provisions.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about limiting public participation. Support for improving meeting efficiency.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina, Councilman Filiberto
Meeting 2023-02 (January 19, 2023):
Appointment of Member to Citizens' Budget Advisory Board
Motion: To appoint Jeffrey McLeod to the at-large position.
Discussion Summary: Debate on applicant qualifications and selection process. Concerns about fairness and preference for another candidate.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina, Councilman Filiberto
Resolution 2023-04, Developing Concealed Carry Policy for City Employees
Motion: To adopt Resolution 2023-04.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about liability, training, and potential escalation of situations.
Voting Outcome: 3-2
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Filiberto
Nays: Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Foster
Amendment to Subrecipient Contract with Community of Hope for ARPA Funding
Motion: To approve the amendment.
Discussion Summary: Discussion on project cost and community impact.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Councilman Filiberto
Reconsideration Request for Ordinance 2022-105 (Waterstone Holdings Development)
Motion: To approve the reconsideration request.
Discussion Summary: Debate on validity of reason for missing previous hearing and potential for future applications.
Voting Outcome: 2-3 (Failed)
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Filiberto
Meeting 2023-03 (February 2, 2023):
Ordinance 2023-04, Granting Ad Valorem Tax Abatement to Rogue Valley Microdevices, Inc.
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2023-04 as first reading with revised abatement percentages.
Discussion Summary: Discussion of potential economic benefits and proposed revisions to abatement percentages. Concerns about impact on city revenue.
Voting Outcome: 4-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Councilman Filiberto
Meeting 2023-06 (March 2, 2023):
Resolution 2023-07, Extending Commencement Period for Self-Storage Facility
Case: CU-6-2022, Willard Palmer
Motion: To adopt Resolution 2023-07 with modification from one-year to six-month extension.
Discussion Summary: Discussion on reasons for project delay and concerns about job creation and suitability of location.
Voting Outcome: 2-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Felix
Nays: Councilman Johnson
Meeting 2023-08 (April 6, 2023):
Ordinance 2023-10, Modifying Provisions for Filling Vacancies on City Council
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2023-10.
Discussion Summary: Mayor disagreed with process for filling vacancy, preferring more public input and longer timeframe. Concerns about transparency and rushed process.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina
Meeting 2023-10 (April 20, 2023):
Continuation of Discussion Regarding Campground Project Next Steps
Motion: To direct staff to negotiate design task order for bridge and other park improvements.
Discussion Summary: Debate on feasibility, cost, and prioritization of bridge, campground, or other park enhancements.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Deputy Mayor Felix
Meeting 2023-14 (May 1, 2023):
Ordinance 2023-25, Approving Final Development Plan for 'Jupiter Bay PUD' (24.69 acres)
Case: FD23-00001, Sachs Capital Group, LP, and Identical Investments, LLC
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2023-25.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about project density and traffic impact despite developer concessions.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina
Request for Preliminary Subdivision Approval for 'Jupiter Bay PUD' (24.69 acres)
Case: PS23-00001
Motion: To approve the request.
Discussion Summary: Similar concerns as previous agenda item regarding density and traffic.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina
Meeting 2023-15 (May 18, 2023):
Ordinance 2022-116, Changing Land Use for 'Palm Vista Everlands West PUD' (1,198.1 acres)
Case: CP-30-2022, Palm Vista Preserve, LLC
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2022-116.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about lack of commercial development and potential impact on traffic/infrastructure. Applicant highlighted mixed-use nature and commercial zoning inclusion.
Voting Outcome: 1-3 (Failed)
Yeas: Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson
Resolution 2023-15, Granting Conditional Use for Retail Store
Case: CU23-00006, David Moallem Trust/Siroos Pirzadeh and Mahnaz Pirzadeh
Motion: To adopt Resolution 2023-15 with condition of adding left-turn lane.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about traffic, turn lanes, and lighting. Applicant agreed to construct turn lane and address lighting.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina
Ordinance 2023-30, Approving Final Development Plan for 'Gardens at Waterstone Phase III' (47.92 acres)
Case: FD23-00004 (formerly FD-63-2022), KB Home Orlando, LLC
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2023-30.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about traffic, infrastructure, and impact fees. Discussion of development agreement and road improvement timeline.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina
Meeting 2023-16 (July 6, 2023):
Resolution 2023-18, Granting Conditional Use for Retail Store
Case: CU23-00002, David Moallem Trust/Siroos Pirzadeh and Mahnaz Pirzadeh
Motion: To adopt Resolution 2023-18 with condition of constructing sidewalks and lighting.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about traffic and need for sidewalks/lighting. Applicant agreed to conditions.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina
Ordinance 2023-41, Including Car Washes in GC Zoning
Case: T23-00010, Anthony Daniele/Royal Wash PSL, LLC
Motion: To deny Ordinance 2023-41.
Discussion Summary: Debate on need for additional car washes and impact on existing businesses.
Voting Outcome: 1-3 (Failed)
Yeas: Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson
Meeting 2023-17 (July 20, 2023):
Ordinance 2023-81, Including Brew Pubs in HC Zoning
Case: T23-00015, City of Palm Bay
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2023-81.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about type of establishment and community impact. Clarification on similarity to existing brew pubs.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina
Ordinance 2023-82, Modifying Setback Requirements for Interchange Signs
Case: T23-00017, All Digital All Day, LLC
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2023-82 with amendment to distance requirement (1,000 ft).
Discussion Summary: Debate on appropriate distance for signage considering visibility and aesthetics.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Deputy Mayor Felix
Meeting 2023-20 (August 17, 2023):
Ordinance 2023-73, Dissolving Citizens' Budget Advisory Board
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2023-73.
Discussion Summary: Citizens and board members opposed dissolution, highlighting citizen engagement and advisory role. Concerns about misinformation and board effectiveness.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina
Ordinance 2023-76, Rezoning Property to RC (6.43 acres)
Case: CPZ23-00008, Merritt Island Holdings, LLC
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2023-76 with condition of no ingress/egress on Waterman Lane.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about traffic, noise, and impact on residential area for proposed grocery store. Applicant addressed concerns.
Voting Outcome: 4-0 (passed, but notably opposed by residents Melanie and Roger Carter)
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Ordinance 2023-81, Including Brew Pubs in HC Zoning
Case: T23-00015, City of Palm Bay
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2023-81.
Discussion Summary: Similar concerns as previous vote on type of establishment and community impact.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina
Ordinance 2023-82, Modifying Setback Requirements for Interchange Signs
Case: T23-00017, All Digital All Day, LLC
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2023-82 with amendment to distance requirement (1,000 ft).
Discussion Summary: Discussion of appropriate distance for signage considering visibility and aesthetics.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Deputy Mayor Felix
Request for Preliminary Subdivision Approval for 'Bayside Landings' (21.00 acres)
Case: PS23-00006
Motion: To approve the request.
Discussion Summary: Discussion of proposed development with townhomes and single-family units. Concerns about traffic and preference for maintaining Institutional Use District zoning for church.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina
Meeting 2023-22 (September 7, 2023):
Ordinance 2023-81, Including Brew Pubs in HC Zoning (Final Reading)
Case: T23-00015, City of Palm Bay
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2023-81
Discussion Summary: Final reading and adoption of the ordinance; Mayor maintained opposition due to concerns about the type of establishment and its potential impact on the community.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina
Ordinance 2023-82, Modifying Setback Requirements for Interchange Signs (Final Reading)
Case: T23-00017, All Digital All Day, LLC
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2023-82
Discussion Summary: Final reading included the amendment to the distance requirement from 1,500 feet to 1,000 feet, with the Deputy Mayor remaining opposed due to preferring a shorter distance.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Deputy Mayor Felix
Resolution 2023-41, Extending Commencement Period for a Self-Storage Facility (Revisitation)
Location: East of and adjacent to Babcock Street, west of Hardin Lane (2.45 acres) (Case CU-45-2022, Fred D. Boozer, Jr.)
Motion: To adopt Resolution 2023-41, with the amendment to grant the extension for six (6) months
Discussion Summary: Discussion on the request for an extension on the commencement period for a self-storage facility; concerns reiterated about the lack of job creation and the need for economic development.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Foster
Nays: Councilman Johnson
Consideration of Additional Funding Requests for Fiscal Year 2024
Motion: To approve additional funding for unfunded capital, operating, and personnel requests, including a full-time veteran service officer and park scoreboards.
Discussion Summary: Debate on the veteran service officer position's cost and necessity, with suggestions for a part-time pilot program.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Deputy Mayor Felix (Opposed only the Veteran Service Officer position)
Meeting 2023-25 (October 5, 2023):
Ordinance 2023-38, Annexation of Property Near Minton Road
Location: West of and adjacent to Minton Road, north of Palm Bay Road and south of Hield Road (2.11 acres)
Applicant: Bruce Coffman/Affordable Trailer Service and Supply, Inc. (Case A23-00002)
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2023-38
Discussion Summary: Residents expressed concerns about traffic, safety, and the impact on the surrounding area; Mayor and Deputy Mayor agreed with concerns about timing and traffic impact.
Voting Outcome: 2-2 (Failed)
Yeas: Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Felix
Meeting 2023-27 (October 19, 2023):
Resolution 2023-38, Conditional Use for Self-Storage Facility (Emerson Drive)
Location: South of and adjacent to Emerson Drive, east of St. Johns Heritage Parkway (3.57 acres) (Case CU23-00007, Ascot Palm Bay Holdings, LLC)
Motion: To adopt Resolution 2023-38.
Discussion Summary: Discussion focused on job creation and alignment with Comprehensive Plan, with concerns about limited job potential of self-storage facilities.
Voting Outcome: 1-3 (Failed)
Yeas: Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson
Resolution 2023-39, Conditional Use for Self-Storage Facility (Martin Road)
Location: West of and adjacent to Martin Road, east of Babcock Street (2.03 acres) (Case CU23-00013, Dan-Nico Properties, LLC)
Motion: To adopt Resolution 2023-39.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about project size and compatibility with neighborhood, but location and undeveloped status led to approval.
Voting Outcome: 4-0 (passed, but notably opposed by resident Donald Foley)
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Ordinance 2023-100, Including Provisions for Small Event Space
Case: T23-00026, City of Palm Bay
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2023-100.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about potential nuisances and impacts on residential areas.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina
Meeting 2023-28 (November 2, 2023):
Ordinance 2023-100, Including Provisions for Small Event Space (Final Reading)
Case: T23-00026, City of Palm Bay
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2023-100.
Discussion Summary: Final reading and adoption; Mayor reiterated concerns about potential crowd size and nuisance issues in residential areas.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina
Meeting 2023-29 (November 14, 2023):
Resolution 2023-41, Extending Commencement Period for Self-Storage Facility (Revisitation)
Location: East of and adjacent to Babcock Street, west of Hardin Lane (2.45 acres) (Case CU-45-2022, Fred D. Boozer, Jr.)
Motion: To adopt Resolution 2023-41 with amendment to grant 6-month extension.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about lack of job creation and need for economic development.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Foster
Nays: Councilman Johnson
Meeting 2023-33 (December 21, 2023):
Ordinance 2023-112, Changing Land Use to High-Density Residential (7.02 acres)
Case: CP23-00018, Treeland Apartments, LLC
Motion: To deny Ordinance 2023-112.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about traffic and suitability for location. Council voted against due to proposed market rate housing and traffic concerns.
Voting Outcome: 3-1 (Failed)
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson
Nays: Councilman Foster
Ordinance 2023-115, Modifying Timelines for Preliminary Development Plan Submittals
Case: T23-00028, City of Palm Bay
Motion: To approve Ordinance 2023-115.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about potential delays and need for efficient project review processes.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson
Nays: Councilman Foster
Meeting 2024-01 (January 4, 2024):
Ordinance 2023-107, Rezoning Property to RS-2 (15.53 acres)
Case: Z23-00014, SKA Properties, LLC
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2023-107.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about impact of increased density on traffic and environment.
Voting Outcome: 2-1 (Failed due to requiring 3 votes for passage)
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson
Nays: Mayor Medina
Meeting 2024-03 (February 1, 2024):
Ordinance 2023-107, Rezoning Property to RS-2 (15.53 acres)
Case: Z23-00014, SKA Properties, LLC
Motion: To adopt Ordinance 2023-107.
Discussion Summary: Rehearing due to question about validity of 2-1 vote. City Attorney clarified 2-1 as sufficient for approval.
Voting Outcome: The previous vote was acknowledged as valid, resulting in approval of the rezoning request.
Consideration of Budget Amendment for Purchase and Rental of Pumps
Motion: To approve budget amendment, standardize pumps, approve emergency procurement, and approve use of Florida Sheriff's Contract.
Discussion Summary: Discussion of need for additional pumps, high cost, and lift station issues in Bayside Lakes. Concerns about City vs. developer responsibility for infrastructure.
Voting Outcome: 4-0
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Meeting 2024-05 (March 7, 2024):
Designating City-Owned Property on Water Drive NE as Surplus
Motion: To approve designating the property as surplus and listing it with the City's real estate broker.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about impact on future U.S. Highway 1 widening and potential need to repurchase land.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Nays: Deputy Mayor Felix
Ordinance 2024-17, Repealing Tax Abatement for Midwest Dental Arts, Inc.
Motion 1: To adopt Ordinance 2024-17 and recover taxes within 90 days.
Discussion Summary: Midwest Dental's difficulty in hiring qualified employees led to failure to meet tax abatement requirements. Discussion on local hiring efforts and accountability.
Voting Outcome 1: 2-2
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Councilman Johnson
Nays: Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Foster
Motion 2: To adopt Ordinance 2024-17 (repeal without specific tax recovery timeframe).
Discussion Summary: Aim to separate repeal decision from tax recovery specifics.
Voting Outcome 2: 2-2
Yeas: Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Foster
Nays: Mayor Medina, Councilman Johnson
Motion 3: To adopt Ordinance 2024-17 and explore options for tax repayment with Midwest Dental.
Discussion Summary: Allow further discussion and negotiation regarding tax repayment.
Voting Outcome 3: 4-0
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson, Councilman Foster
Program Year 2024 Annual Action Plan and CDBG Funding Recommendations
Motion: To approve the Annual Action Plan and CDBG funding recommendations.
Discussion Summary: Concerns about CDAB scoring process fairness and transparency raised by Esther Theological Seminary representatives.
Voting Outcome: 3-1
Yeas: Mayor Medina, Deputy Mayor Felix, Councilman Johnson
Nays: Councilman Foster
Excellent Article to be used to review how we will vote .