The Vanishing: 17 Years of Unanswered Questions in the Brandy Hall Case

A tangled web of love, lies, and a missing gun - Brandy Hall's disappearance continues to cast a long shadow over Palm Bay.

May 15, 2024

Palm Bay, Florida – Seventeen years ago, the humid August air carried the scent of barbecue smoke and the laughter of children playing in the twilight. But for Debbie Rogge, the warmth of that summer evening would soon turn icy cold, replaced by a chilling fear that continues to grip her heart. Her daughter, Brandy Hall, a 32-year-old firefighter, wife, and mother of two, vanished without a trace, leaving behind a void that echoes through the years.

Brandy was a force of nature, a tomboy from a young age who could fix anything, ride horses with fearless abandon, and navigate an airboat through the Florida swamps with the skill of a seasoned outdoorsman. A childhood ATV accident left her with facial scars and a lifetime of migraines, but it also ignited a passion to help others, leading her to pursue a career as a firefighter.

“She was a natural,” Debbie recalls, her voice choked with emotion. “She could take anything apart and put it back together. And she had this drive, this determination to make a difference."

Brandy joined the Palm Bay Fire Department in 1994, one of only a handful of female firefighters at the time. She excelled in her work, earning praise from her superiors and inspiring those around her. But behind the facade of a dedicated public servant, Brandy’s life was entangled in a complex web of relationships and secrets.

Her marriage to Jeff Hall, a former fire chief in Osceola County, was strained by his involvement in a large-scale marijuana grow operation. While Jeff maintains that Brandy knew nothing about his illegal activities, evidence suggests otherwise. A police report from the time of his arrest states that Brandy admitted to knowing about the operation and even warned Jeff he would eventually get caught.

The strain on their marriage was compounded by Brandy’s decade-long affair with Randall Richmond, a fire captain in Palm Bay. Their relationship, a poorly kept secret within the fire department, introduced a volatile mix of passion, jealousy, and potential danger.

The night Brandy vanished, she was scheduled to work a full shift at the Malabar Fire Station but left early, telling a colleague she needed to go home. Her last known phone call was to Randall, a cryptic 10-minute conversation that ended just before midnight.

The following day, Brandy’s truck was discovered submerged in a remote pond on the Brevard Community College campus, a location she and Randall were known to frequent. The chilling discovery of a significant amount of Brandy's dried blood inside the cab, combined with the fact that her gun was missing, pointed towards foul play.

“The blood, the missing gun – it all screamed homicide,” says retired detective Sid LaDow, who dedicated years of his retirement to investigating Brandy's disappearance. "We knew right then that something terrible had happened to her."

Despite exhaustive searches of the pond and surrounding areas, Brandy’s body was never recovered. The lack of a body has presented a significant challenge for investigators, making it difficult to determine the exact cause and manner of death, and hindering the ability to build a strong case.

Randall, already a person of interest due to the affair, became a focal point of the investigation. His initial lies to police about the extent of his relationship with Brandy, his inconsistent statements about his whereabouts the night she vanished, and his access to a second, less conspicuous, fire captain vehicle raised a multitude of red flags.

“Randall’s behavior from the start was incredibly suspicious,” says retired detective Doc Jones, who partnered with Sid on the case. “He lied, he was evasive, and he refused to take a polygraph test. It all pointed toward a man trying to conceal his involvement in something terrible."

The investigation took a dramatic turn when a long-lost tip from Officer Jasmine Campbell surfaced years after Brandy’s disappearance. Campbell reported seeing a fire captain's vehicle at a Hess gas station near I-95 shortly after Brandy’s last phone call with Randall. This critical detail, overlooked for years, placed a vehicle similar to one Randall could have been using in close proximity to Brandy’s truck the night she vanished, directly contradicting his initial alibi.

The revelation of the lost tip, combined with Sid and Doc’s relentless pursuit of answers, led the Palm Bay Police Department to re-energize their efforts. A new detective was assigned to the case, and the department sought the help of private investigator Nick Sanberg, a former Palm Bay police officer with extensive experience in cold cases, to take over for the late Sid LaDow.

Sanberg, driven by a desire to bring closure to Brandy's family, has re-examined the evidence, re-interviewed witnesses, and explored new avenues of investigation. He has also raised questions about the initial portrayal of Jeff Hall’s grow operation, noting inconsistencies that suggest a larger and more sophisticated enterprise than initially presented, potentially involving unknown individuals and motives.

“We are committed to leaving no stone unturned,” Sanberg states. “This case is far from cold, and we believe there are still answers to be found.”

The discovery of a camouflaged backpack containing Brandy’s belongings in a canal in Vero Beach a year after her disappearance added another layer of complexity to the case. The backpack, weighed down with steel plates, contained clothing, pornographic DVDs, erectile dysfunction cream, and an address book with Brandy’s name. The timing of its disposal, occurring after the canal was drained for a hurricane, suggests a deliberate attempt to conceal the bag and its contents.

The backpack discovery, along with a later finding of Brandy’s old fire helmet near Mather’s Bridge in Indian Harbour Beach, has raised the possibility of planted evidence, potentially designed to mislead investigators or taunt the police.

While Randall remains a primary suspect, other individuals, including Jeff Hall, his former drug partner Paul Hirsch, and Annmarie Richmond, Randall’s ex-wife, continue to be persons of interest. Annmarie, who had a documented confrontation with Brandy at the Grant Seafood Festival and exchanged angry text messages with her, has been highlighted by forensic psychologist Richard Walter as a potential suspect, citing her motive (jealousy over the affair) and opportunity.

The Brandy Hall case has become a frustrating puzzle with missing pieces, conflicting accounts, and a haunting absence at its core. But despite the passage of time, the case remains alive, driven by the enduring hope that justice will be served.

“We will never give up on Brandy,” says Debbie, her voice resolute. “She deserves justice, her children deserve answers, and our family deserves closure. We believe that someone out there knows what happened to her, and we pray that one day they will find the courage to come forward.”

The search for Brandy Hall continues, a testament to the unwavering love of a mother, the dedication of investigators, and the persistent belief that even in the darkest corners of mystery, the truth can be found.

For more information on Palm Bay news, be sure to visit The Palm Bayer.